Sign Up!

To receive
ATorahMinute daily

Women's corner

providing a weekly Torah minute for women.

See what people are saying about Here.

The stimulating "A TORAH MINUTE" books.

The critically acclaimed A Torah Minute Book, Vol. 2, TORAH GEMS AND PRACTICAL LAWS, by Rabbi Ya'aqob Menashe, with a Women's Corner by Rabbanith Ruth Menashe.

Click here to order.


300 Gems from the Ben Ish Hai
It is incredible how only one minute a day can impact your entire life.
A Torah Minute: 300 Gems from the Ben Ish Hai. Including the Women's Corner.
Get more information here. is a project of Midrash BEN ISH HAI where you can learn Torah anytime. It will send you a short Daily Halacha or daily Torah by Rabbi Ya'aqob Menashe.

Rabbi Ya'aqob Menashe often draws his inspiration for his Halakhoth (Halachot) and pearls of Torah from the Ben Ish Hai, Hakham Yoseph Hayyim, 'a"h. In addition, the daily bulletins include a wide variety of sources: Shulhan Arukh (Shulchan Aruch), Kaf Hahayim (Kaf Hachaim), Mishnah Berurah (Mishna Brura) and many other sources.


To receive these daily pearls of wisdom and sign up for our Torah email list, click here.






Play / Download audio as MP3
(Length: 1:01, 1 MB)

If One Must Recite the Shema' in an Unclean Place

Rabbi Ya'aqob Menashe
Tuesday, November 14, 2017/Heshwan 25, 5778

Even though we say that one who recites the Shema' in his mind alone, with no sound emanating from his mouth, has not fulfilled his obligation of reading the Shema', nevertheless, if he is unable to read it aloud because he is ill, or for some other reason out of his control, he does fulfill his obligation.

As a matter of fact, he should read it in his mind only, even initially, if he is in an unclean place, assuming that he is unable to clean it (or go elsewhere). This is considered to be "Oness" (being out of one's control). If one is able to read it again later in a clean place, before the time for its recitation has passed, one should do so.

If, however, the place is not just unclean, but contains actual filth of the type where one is forbidden to even think of words of Torah, then one may not recite the Shema' in one's mind. In such a case, if the person desires to recite the Shema' and is pained at not being able to do so, G-d considers it as if he had recited it.

(See Shulhan 'Arukh, with Rama, 62:4. Kaf Hahayyim, ibid, Oth 8. Mishnah Berurah, ibid., 9)

Shema' Yisrael, Shma Yisroel, Reciting the Shema in a dirty place

Print this
Bookmark and Share

Search A Torah Minute

Enter search term
or search by date